Captain vs. No Captain: What’s the Difference?

Understanding Your Options Before You Book

When booking a boat through BoatSitterUS, one of the first decisions you’ll make is whether to hire a captain or operate the vessel yourself. Each option offers a different kind of experience, and the right choice depends on your comfort level, your group, and the type of day you want.

What Is a Captained Charter?

With a captained charter, a licensed, USCG-certified professional will operate the boat for you. It’s the most popular option for good reason—your job is simply to relax while they handle everything else.

Benefits include:

• Stress-free navigation
  
• Local knowledge of sandbars, hidden coves, and safe routes
  
• Help anchoring, docking, and managing onboard safety
  
• A smoother experience for first-timers or large groups
  

Captains also serve as guides, hosts, and safety managers—especially helpful for special occasions like birthdays or bachelorette parties.

What Is a Bareboat (Non-Captained) Charter?

This option allows you to operate the boat yourself. Bareboat rentals are only available for select vessels and require that you meet specific criteria:

• Minimum age of 21
  
• Proof of boating license or qualifying experience
  
• Signed waiver and added responsibility for safety, navigation, and damages
  

It offers more independence and can reduce cost—but it also places full responsibility for guest safety and vessel management on you.

Liability and Insurance Considerations

When you hire a captain, the charter typically falls under commercial insurance with the captain assuming operational liability. Without a captain, you are personally liable for damage, incidents, and legal compliance while on the water.

Make sure you’re confident in both your boating skills and your familiarity with local laws before selecting this option.

So Which Should You Choose?

Choose a captain if:

• You want to relax and enjoy the ride
  
• You’re celebrating something or hosting a group
  
• You’re unfamiliar with the waterways or local boating rules
  

Go bareboat if:

• You have the experience and credentials
  
• You want full control over the itinerary
  
• You’re looking for a more casual, DIY vibe
  

Browse Boats With or Without a Captain